Ask Your Question

ApproximateTime Synchronizer executed by multiple nodes: collision?

asked 2014-04-27 01:40:40 -0500

Tinrik gravatar image

updated 2014-04-27 04:35:34 -0500

Hi all,

Right now I have a node RGBDImageProc that does some processing on the incoming data from an RGBD camera. It's a slightly modified version of the one here:

Now I want to use this node with multiple cameras. What I do is to launch 2 instances of this node, each one inside a different namespace and connected to a different camera. The launching works fine and each camera publishes all the information into independent topics. For instance: /cam1/camera/rgb/..., /cam2/camera/rgb/... I can view the images of both cameras simultaneously using image_viewer so they are publishing properly.

My problem comes at the processing node. Right now it's using an ApproximateTime Synchronizer to process the information from the RGB and Depth information in a single Callback, like this:

RGBDImageProc::RGBDImageProc(const ros::NodeHandle& nh, const ros::NodeHandle& nh_private): nh_(nh), nh_private_(nh_private), rgb_image_transport_(nh_), depth_image_transport_(nh_), config_server_(nh_private_), size_in_(0,0){


// subscribers

sub_rgb_.subscribe (rgb_image_transport_, "/"+cam_name_+"/camera/rgb/image", queue_size_);

sub_depth_.subscribe(depth_image_transport_, "/"+cam_name_+"/camera/depth/image_raw", queue_size_);

sub_rgb_info_.subscribe (nh_, "/"+cam_name_+"/camera/rgb/camera_info", queue_size_);

sub_depth_info_.subscribe(nh_, "/"+cam_name_+"/camera/depth/camera_info", queue_size_);

sync_.reset(new RGBDSynchronizer4(RGBDSyncPolicy4(queue_size_), sub_rgb_, sub_depth_, sub_rgb_info_, sub_depth_info_));

sync_->registerCallback(boost::bind(&RGBDImageProc::RGBDCallback, this, _1, _2, _3, _4)); }

The callback is:

void RGBDImageProc::RGBDCallback( const ImageMsg::ConstPtr& rgb_msg, const ImageMsg::ConstPtr& depth_msg, const CameraInfoMsg::ConstPtr& rgb_info_msg, const CameraInfoMsg::ConstPtr& depth_info_msg) {
std::cout<<"RGBD Callback...\n";

The class header contains the following:


ros::NodeHandle nh_;          ///< the public nodehandle
ros::NodeHandle nh_private_;  ///< the private nodehandle

boost::shared_ptr<RGBDSynchronizer4> sync_; ///< ROS 4-topic synchronizer

ImageTransport rgb_image_transport_;    ///< ROS image transport for rgb message
ImageTransport depth_image_transport_;  ///< ROS image transport for depth message

ImageSubFilter sub_rgb_;   ///< ROS subscriber for rgb message
ImageSubFilter sub_depth_; ///< ROS subscriber for depth message

CameraInfoSubFilter sub_rgb_info_;   ///< ROS subscriber for rgb camera info
CameraInfoSubFilter sub_depth_info_; ///< ROS subscriber for depth camera info


typedef image_transport::ImageTransport ImageTransport;

typedef image_transport::SubscriberFilter ImageSubFilter;

typedef message_filters::Subscriber<camerainfomsg> CameraInfoSubFilter;

typedef message_filters::sync_policies::ApproximateTime<imagemsg, imagemsg,="" camerainfomsg=""> RGBDSyncPolicy3;

typedef message_filters::sync_policies::ApproximateTime<imagemsg, imagemsg,="" camerainfomsg,="" camerainfomsg=""> RGBDSyncPolicy4;

typedef message_filters::Synchronizer<rgbdsyncpolicy3> RGBDSynchronizer3;

typedef message_filters::Synchronizer<rgbdsyncpolicy4> RGBDSynchronizer4;

If I first run one camera, under the namespace /cam1/..., everything works perfectly, and the RGBDCallback is executed. However, when I start the second camera (with the first one still running), under the namespace /cam2/..., the RGBDCallback is not executed anymore, either for cam1 or for cam2 (in this case, it never runs a single call).

Tracking the error, I found out that it hangs after doing sync_->registerCallback(...) in cam2.

Are the two Synchronizers colliding somehow? How could I solve this problem?

Thank you very much.

P.S.: sorry for the bad code formatting, I don't know how to fix it.

edit retag flag offensive close merge delete

2 Answers

Sort by ยป oldest newest most voted

answered 2014-04-30 22:04:53 -0500

Tinrik gravatar image

updated 2014-07-04 16:20:54 -0500

Any hints? It seems like my callback function is not being called, but there is information being published into the corresponding topics. Is there any way I can "see" what is going on after receiving the data and before the callback (which is not called), or if the node actually receives the data?


EDIT: I finally found what the problem was. It has nothing to do with the software, which is perfectly fine. It seems that my cameras were connected to the same USB 2.0 bus (but different ports), so when I tried to get RGB + Depth from both of them simultaneously there was not enough bandwidth for them and thus there was a collision.

Having the two cameras on different USB buses solved the problem :)

edit flag offensive delete link more

answered 2014-07-04 15:41:16 -0500

Dyna gravatar image

Same problem here ! Do you find a solution ?

edit flag offensive delete link more


Yep, see my edited answer!

Tinrik gravatar image Tinrik  ( 2014-07-04 16:21:20 -0500 )edit

Ok thanks !

Dyna gravatar image Dyna  ( 2014-07-05 01:22:25 -0500 )edit

Your Answer

Please start posting anonymously - your entry will be published after you log in or create a new account.

Add Answer

Question Tools


Asked: 2014-04-27 01:40:40 -0500

Seen: 401 times

Last updated: Jul 04 '14