Attention: Answers.ros.org is deprecated as of August the 11th, 2023. Please visit robotics.stackexchange.com to ask a new question. This site will remain online in read-only mode during the transition and into the foreseeable future. Selected questions and answers have been migrated, and redirects have been put in place to direct users to the corresponding questions on Robotics Stack Exchange. Additional details are available here.

Best choice for controlling GPIOs (published messages or service calls)

asked 2015-01-12 15:19:52 -0500

epascual
68 ●3 ●5 ●4

Hello,

Sorry if this is an already answered question, but despite a couple of hours spent googling the Web and searching in this forum, I couldn't find.

What is the rule of thumb for deciding if some control operation should be implemented using published messages or service calls ?

For controlling robot moves, I could see that the standard way is to use Twist messages published on the /cmd_vel topic. But what about controlling GPIOs for instance ? Should this be using published messages too or service calls ?

Since there is no feedback when using messages (you can't know if somebody heard them and process them), I would be tempted to use service calls instead.

Thanks in advance for any advice. Best regards. Eric

edit retag flag offensive close merge delete

add a comment

1 Answer

Sort by » oldest newest most voted

answered 2015-01-12 17:21:54 -0500

Dan Lazewatsky
9115 ●79 ●103 ●160 http://dan.lazewatsky.com/

The best choice is going to depend on your particular application.

A few rules of thumb:

If you need to guarantee that the other node got the message, use a service
If you need a response, use a service (or an action)
If you need speed, use a topic
If you don't care if every message goes through, use a topic
If you are interacting with some existing topic/service API, use whatever that API already uses

Note that it also doesn't have to be one or the other. Some nodes (such as move_base) provide both a topic and action API for the same thing.

edit flag offensive delete link

Comments

Thanks Dan for you quick reply. You confirm what I had concluded from studying existing material. The very last point was also something I had in mind. Regards.

epascual ( 2015-01-13 01:18:24 -0500 )edit

add a comment

Question Tools

1 follower

Stats

Asked: 2015-01-12 15:19:52 -0500

Seen: 174 times

Last updated: Jan 12 '15

Best choice for controlling GPIOs (published messages or service calls) edit

1 Answer

Comments

Question Tools

Stats

Related questions

Best choice for controlling GPIOs (published messages or service calls)