The relationship between tf in rviz and tf_echo is very different
When I do simulation experiments with gazebo+rviz, the relationship of each frame of tf in the rviz screen is accurate, my concern is the relationship of the coordinate transformations of wamv/odom and wamv/baselink, which is shown in rviz to be ‘[30.581, 2.674, -0.1031]’, but running in the terminal rosrun tf tfecho wamv/base_link wamv/odom gets ‘- Translation: [-27.193, 9.677, 0.484]’, especially in the Y direction.
Asked by lohwanyan on 2023-07-31 07:36:39 UTC
Comments
Hi!
Are you sure to have specified the two RF in the same order in both cases. The problem might be that on one side you are looking at the
odom
tobase_link
transformation, and on the other one you are lookingbase_link
toodom
.The reason why I am suggesting this is that Rviz is just a visualization tool. The information that you are looking to are in the end published by
tf
itself in both cases (Rviz and terminal), thus it would be weird that they do not coincide.If this is not the case, adding some more info about your situation (e.g. the Rviz visualization of the two frames) could help us have a better understanding of the problem.
Asked by bluegiraffe-sc on 2023-07-31 09:05:09 UTC
I found out where the problem was. Because the order of 'source_frame' and 'target_frame' in the command
rosrun tf tf_echo wamv/base_link wamv/odom
was reversed. But I understood that the reverse order should give the opposite result, but it didn't turn out to be the case.Asked by lohwanyan on 2023-07-31 20:33:37 UTC
Glad you solved, you can post the solution as an answer to your question for future readers.
About the "the reverse order should give the opposite result", the key to understand this in the tf docs, where it says
In your case, to go from
base_link
toodom
you apply a translation expressed inbase_link
RF and then rotate. To go back, you first apply a rotation inodom
RF and then rotate. The two transforms are indeed "opposite", but as they are not expressed wrt the same RF, it is not just a matter of putting a minus sign in front.Asked by bluegiraffe-sc on 2023-08-01 02:45:18 UTC
yes,i seem know ,thanks a lot
Asked by lohwanyan on 2023-08-01 21:47:09 UTC