Order of catkin source setup.bash files matters?

asked 2014-03-06 05:02:07 -0500

baxelrod

794 ●20 ●24 ●34 http://benaxelrod.com/

updated 2016-10-24 09:01:12 -0500

ngrennan
1 ●1 ●1

I have these lines in my .bashrc file:

source /opt/ros/hydro/setup.bash
source /home/baxelrod/my_catkin_ws/devel/setup.bash
source /home/baxelrod/my_other_catkin_ws/devel/setup.bash

Which yields this environment variable:

ROS_PACKAGE_PATH=/home/baxelrod/my_other_catkin_ws/src:
                 /home/baxelrod/my_catkin_ws/src:
                 /opt/ros/hydro/share:
                 /opt/ros/hydro/stacks

However, when I change the order of "source" lines in my .bashrc to have "my_other_catkin_ws" before "my_catkin_ws", close and open a new terminal, then the ROS_PACKAGE_PATH becomes:

ROS_PACKAGE_PATH=/home/baxelrod/my_catkin_ws/src:
                 /opt/ros/hydro/share:
                 /opt/ros/hydro/stacks

What gives?

More info:

I am using ROS Hydro on Ubuntu 12.04.
Both catkin workspaces are compiled.
The workspaces were created at different times. my_catkin_ws is significantly newer than my_other_catkin_ws. (I updated my ROS packages a few times in between.) This is strange because it seems like sourcing my_catkin_ws (the newer workspace) clobbers the existing path. So it seems like maybe a bug was introduced.
I diffed both setup.bash and setup.sh files and there are no differences besides the path to the workspace

edit retag flag offensive close merge delete

add a comment

5

answered 2014-03-06 05:24:11 -0500

Dirk Thomas
16276 ●62 ●190 ●215

The order of sourcing multiple setup files does not matter. Since the last one will overwrite all environment variables anyway.

What does matter is the environment you used when creating these workspaces. At the initial configure time the current environment (basically the CMAKE_PREFIX_PATH defining the already sourced workspaces which you want to overlay) is extended with the environment for this new workspace.

You can not overlay my_catkin_ws and my_other_catkin_ws by just sourcing both setup files if they been created independently in the first place.

edit flag offensive delete link

Comments

Ugh. That's a pain. I really liked the old rosmake pattern of appending different directories to ROS_PACKAGE_PATH in your .bashrc. Are you saying that when you create a catkin workspace, it stores some environment variables to file? This seems dangerous.

baxelrod ( 2014-03-06 06:00:04 -0500 )edit

It is necessary. If you build a program in workspace B which uses a library in A, then you "add" workspace C which contains a modified version of the library in A, then when you run the program in B it will have been built against library in workspace A, but dynamically link against the library from workspace C. There are other ways this kind of workspace composing can be bad, and it will bite you eventually.

William ( 2014-03-06 06:18:47 -0500 )edit

You can compose them using the `--extend` option to the `setup.*` files, but use at your own risk...

William ( 2014-03-06 06:19:13 -0500 )edit

It does not store all environment variable but only which workspace it is supposed to overlay. So basically only the CMAKE_PREFIX_PATH. The other environment variable are then generated on-the-fly when you source the setup.

Dirk Thomas ( 2014-03-06 06:24:19 -0500 )edit

add a comment

2

answered 2016-11-16 09:00:19 -0500

peci1

1366 ●27 ●69 ●60

Check out the catkin tools package. It allows you to specify explicit workspaces to extend:

catkin config --extend /opt/ros/indigo
catkin build

makes sure that you always build the workspace with only /opt/ros/indigo as parent workspace (regardless of your current environment).

edit flag offensive delete link

Comments

I highly recommend this approach. Explicitly passing the overlaid workspace avoids all the confusion caused by using the wrong environment. We all make that mistake sometimes.

joq ( 2016-11-16 09:29:27 -0500 )edit

add a comment

Order of catkin source setup.bash files matters?

2 Answers

Comments

Comments

Question Tools

Stats

Related questions

Order of catkin source setup.bash files matters? edit

2 Answers

Comments

Comments

Question Tools

Stats

Related questions

Order of catkin source setup.bash files matters?