Ask Your Question
0

Which Robot for ROS?

asked Jan 31

Cav gravatar image Cav
140 3 11

Hi,

which of the supported robots would you recommend for using with ROS (educational purposes)? Turtlebot seems to lead the way but are there any real alternatives? Anything that comes close to Turtlebot (and is in the same/similar price range)?

delete close flag offensive retag edit

3 Answers

Sort by ยป oldest newest most voted
5

answered Jan 31

DimitriProsser gravatar image DimitriProsser flag of United States
6817 23 59 126

I would say that the Turtlebot is the most well-supported platform on these forums, just out of experience. That is not to say that other robots aren't well-supported, but there are lots of tutorials and help for Turtlebot users. I'm not sure of any other robots really in that price range.

link delete flag offensive edit

Comments

Additionally, I will add that the TurtleBot has a growing community with over 450 official TurtleBots sold and about 100 more homemade robots (even Bilibot is using the TurtleBot stacks as a basis). Many professors have already started creating curriculum around the TurtleBot that you could use. mwise_wg (Jan 31)edit
1

answered Jan 31

JeffRousseau gravatar image JeffRousseau
1141 15 21 34
http://jeffrousseau.info/

The Bilibot platform offers similar features to the Turtlebot and has an integrated "powerboard" that allows for a single charger. I believe the Turtlebot requires separate chargers for the computer and the iRobot Create, whereas the Bilibot has one plug to power/charge the create and the main computer supply. It also has Intel i3 processor that's a bit beefier than the dual-atom you get in the Turtlebot's netbook. Plus it ships with an arm (albeit very limited).

Unfortunately, other than basic setup instructions the documentation/tutorials for the Bilibot platform are severely lacking. As a contributing member of the project, I'm working with my local university to help find and fix some holes in that area over the upcoming semester (they purchased a number of them as general-purpose ROS machines).

link delete flag offensive edit
1

answered Jan 31

Murph gravatar image Murph
483 1 14 35
http://localhost/

I've just built my own basically-a-turtlebot with a netbook, an iRobot Create, and a kinect. It's not as 100% pretty, but it works well.

Basically this, but the latest one uses a turtlebot power board instead of the handmade one since it included a gyro that I needed.

link delete flag offensive edit

Comments

I too have gone the "build my own turtlebot workalike" route, as have many others. It works quite well. Mac (Jan 31)edit

Your answer

Please start posting your answer anonymously - your answer will be saved within the current session and published after you log in or create a new account. Please try to give a substantial answer, for discussions, please use comments and please do remember to vote (after you log in)!
[hide preview]

Question tools

Follow
1 follower

subscribe to rss feed

Stats

Asked: Jan 31

Seen: 129 times

Last updated: Jan 31