Scores of tod_detecting / tod_training in "Solutions in Perceptions Challenge 2011" , details available?

asked May 21 '11

Julius
565 ● 1 ● 13 ● 26

Hello, are there details on how well ROS packages tod_training and tod_detecting performed at "Solutions in Perceptions Challenge 2011" at ICRA in Shanghai 2011? These two ROS packages have been used for comparison to solutions submitted by participating contesters. According to the score function, winner's team got ca. 69% of max. score and tod_training+tod_detecting combo got 50.86%. The results are nice, but I am wondering about the tod_training+tod_detecting combo:

choice of algorithms
choice of hyperparameters
used svn revision
handling of limited computation times

For those accustomed to tod_*, it burns down to the question, whether one of the svn revisions has been used in the contest without further modification, and what the features.config.yaml and config.yaml (describing the parameter set) have looked like.

image description

btw, this is the report which I am missing as well as the parameter configuration.

delete close flag offensive retag edit

Comments

I have also been foraying for further information on the OpenCV mailing list, see http://tech.groups.yahoo.com/group/OpenCV/message/80424 . Anybody investigating into this matter as well? Julius (May 29 '11)edit

I also attempted to ask guys from the challenge directly. Maybe some of the information has been presented only verbally at ICRA itself. There's no presentations or details on the Challenge website (neither on YouTube). Anyone in the community had the opportunity to watch the Challenge in Shanghai? Julius (May 29 '11)edit

1 Answer

Sort by » oldest newest most voted

answered Jun 17 '11

ethanrublee
225 ● 2 ● 4

The version of TOD used for the contest is a private version that was forced into the contest stub code. This is not a public repository.

tod_* is in a state of flux, and will soon be removed in its current form. Please do not depend on it, or expect it to work.

link delete flag offensive edit

Question tools

2 followers

Stats

Asked: May 21 '11

Seen: 70 times

Last updated: Jun 17 '11

Scores of tod_detecting / tod_training in "Solutions in Perceptions Challenge 2011" , details available?

Comments

1 Answer

Your answer

Question tools

Stats

Related questions